10 Of The Most Amazing Mascaras Every Girl Should Own

(Last Updated On: December 9, 2018)

Table of Contents

10 Of The Most Amazing Mascaras Every Girl Should Own

Enduring in popularity, the mascara is instant applied beauty, whenever needed, adding thickness, length, and a darker color to the lashes, that draws attention to the eyes and gives them definition. That’s why it’s all over Amazon. Girls just couldn’t have enough of mascara. We’re here to compile ten of the best you can find and surely any one of these can be a favorite, and for keeps.

L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara, Carbon Black, 0.26 fl. oz.

$7.95
$5.84  in stock
1 new from $5.84
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • Bold, volume building mascara
  • Up to 5x fuller lashes
  • Separates and builds every lash
  • Clump-free and Smudge-resistant mascara

Why you need it?

The No 1 best seller of all time is L’Oréal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara. It talks volumes, literally, and in just one apply gets the desired results. It’ll give you 5x the thickness of your old lashes and pretty much stays in place. What’s more, it not pricy. With tons of girls having this in their beauty kit, how could you go wrong?

What is it?  

0.8 oz of Original Volume-Building Mascara and Volume Maximizing Brush. Contains Panthenol and Ceramide-R and helps protect and condition lashes. Resists clumping and flaking, and leaves lashes supple and soft to the touch. By L’Oreal Paris. Tips: Place brush at base of lashes and gently sweep up to tip. Removes easily with soap and water. Do not dilute mascara with water, saliva, or any other substance; cap tightly after use.

Pros

  • Huge majority of users simply are in love with the product; applies smoothly, stays all day, lashes are long and beautiful, lashes look fuller, waterproof, better than expensive brands.
  • No clumping, smudging, no ‘spider eyes’, does not irritate eyes.

Cons

  • Negatives include: clumping, flaking; can get too much product on the brush.
  • L’Oreal’s other mascaras are better.


Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara by Simply Naked Beauty. Last All Day, waterproof, smudge proof & hypoallergenic ingredients. non-toxic and natural. Midnight Black

$21.97
$19.99  in stock
1 new from $19.99
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • LIMITED TIME OFFER! Buy 2 and get 10% off using this code on checkout: XOFJI3W2
  • LAST ALL DAY, WATEPROOF & SMUDGE PROOF - Lash Science will last all day, is waterproof, sweat proof and smudge proof. Bring on 24-hour sexy.
  • HIGHEST QUALITY NON-TOXIC, NATURAL & SAFE INGREDIENTS - Lash Science is made from natural, non-irritating and non-toxic ingredients like 100% natural green tea fibers perfect for sensitive skin. Hypoallergenic ingredients and never tested on animals. Paraben free.
  • 300x LASH VOLUME IN 5 MINUTES -Lash Science 3D Fiber mascara will give you the most volume and length outside of extensions, guaranteed.
  • SUPER EASY TO APPLY - With the most detailed and easy to follow directions you have ever seen and a customer support team of beauty specialist, Lash Science goes on so quick, you'll be amazed. Comes off easily and fast.

Why you need it?

Want your mascara to last all day, very black and very full? No problem with that with 3D Fiber Lash Mascara by Simply Naked Beauty. It’s highest reviewed. For you ladies out there with sparse, thin lashes, complete your makeup with this; use it every day. It’s all your lashes need to stay put from sunrise to a whole night of partying. It’s sexy yet it’s all science. Your very 3D lashes are all natural ingredients of the highest quality, so it’s safe to use.

What is it?  

Lash Science 3D Fiber mascara guaranteed to give the most volume and length outside of extensions and false eyelashes. Applies 300x lash volume in 5 minutes. All day mascara, waterproof and smudge-proof, using only natural and non-toxic ingredients.

Pros

  • Many buyers are impressed with the mascara: lashes are big and beautiful, dramatic effect, mistaken for false eyelashes, stays on the whole day.
  • No eye irritation or itchiness, no clumping, no transfer of fibers.
  • Results are amazing after a brief learning curve.
  • Elegant casing, great price, good customer service.

Cons

  • Expressions of disappointments: flaking, clumping, falling fibers, not waterproof.
  • Two-step application is time consuming, 3 to 5 coats is too much, a lot of work to put on.


All Natural Organic Mascara | Black | Vegan & Cruelty Free | For Lash Growth, Lengthening and Volume | Best Gluten Free Eyelash Conditioning Eye Makeup | Volumizing & Washable Mascara | Made in USA

$29.99
$19.99  in stock
1 new from $19.99
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • MAKES LASHES LOOK LONGER AND FULLER - Voluminous mascara that goes on smoothly without clumps, flakes, or smudges. It is great for thickening and lengthening lashes.
  • ALL NATURAL ORGANIC MAKE UP - This mascara is non toxic and free of harmful chemicals. It is good for sensitive eyes and contact wearers and enriched with nourishing ingredients that promote eyelash growth.
  • STAYS ON ALL DAY - This long lasting natural mascara is not waterproof, but it is water resistant and sweatproof. It is is easy to apply and easy to remove from your lashes at the end of the day.
  • MAKES A GREAT GIFT - This mascara works great and makes a perfect gift for your mother, sister, wife, daughter or girlfriend, whatever the occasion!
  • Doesn't everyone want SOFT, HEALTHY, LUSH LASHES? Grab yours today! Risk-Free Purchase - 30 DAY MONEY BACK GUARANTEE!

Why you need it?

Are your eyes and the skin around your eyes too sensitive? Do you experience falling lashes with your old mascara? If so, those might be the reasons you don’t use mascara as often. Suffer no more and grab this. Endlessly Beautiful All Natural Organic Mascara ensures you that it’s safe to use around your eyes. And no more of those falling lashes, in fact, they grow back! It’s all natural and organic.    

What is it?  

Mascara made from 100% natural and 85% organic ingredients, vegan and gluten free. Enriched with lash nourishing ingredients including Chamomile, Vitamin E, Oregano, Thyme, Coffee Powder, Cinnamon, Rosemary and Grapefruit that condition and stimulate lash growth. Tube is compact and travel friendly; even smells good. As with any product, and especially if you have sensitive eyes or skin, be sure to test this product on a patch of skin for 24-48 hours before applying to the eyes.

Pros

  • Many love the mascara for its more natural look, no smudging or clumping, no smearing or flaking, small size tube make up for performance, smooth application.
  • Not for those who want long full lashes but just everyday, natural-looking lashes.
  • Noticeable growing lashes, nice scent.

Cons

  • Reports of allergic reactions, red puffy eyes. Creates smudges, smears, racoon eyes.  
  • Product is too small, not worth the price.


3D Fiber Lash Mascara - Best for Thickening & Lengthening - Paraben-Free - Highest Quality Natural & Non-Toxic Hypoallergenic Ingredients - Includes Bonus Eyelash eBook with Pro-Tips (Black Mascara)

$50.00
$19.96  in stock
2 new from $19.96
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • New Packaging and Improved Formula Made to Maximize Volume & Length in Thin Short Eyelashes in 3 Easy Steps!
  • WATER & SMUDGE Resistant - Clump Free Formula that wears all day... No Raccoon Eyes.
  • Natural Non Toxic Ingredients - Strengthen and Condition Your Natural Eye Lashes. Never tested on Animals
  • Includes: 1 Tube of WET Magnifying Mascara Gel & 1 Tube of DRY Micro Fibers PLUS recyclable carrying case.
  • Lasts ALL DAY! Best Fiber Mascara Ever! Featured in 2017 Celebrity gift bags!

Why you need it?

Here’s another thickening and lengthening mascara to love. The Mia Dora 3D Fiber Lash Mascara got tons of reviews attesting to its wide popularity among the ladies. Comes with an Eyelash eBook with Pro-Tips to ensure you get its 3-step application right. You’ll love that it’s paraben-free and hypoallergenic.   

What is it?  

Mascara made with natural ingredients that conditions and nourishes eyelashes while magnifying them using 3D Fibers made with Green Tea! Paraben and SLS Free and non-tested on animals.  Brushes on like regular mascara in 3 simple steps. Comes in one tube of WET Magnifying Mascara Gel & one tube of DRY Micro Fibers and carrying case. It’s buildable, contains no glue, non-irritating ingredients so it’s safe for contact lens wearers.

Pros

  • A very good majority say it’s the mascara they’re looking for; beautifully thick and long lashes, dramatic look for thin, sparse lashes, like eyelash extensions.
  • Easy application, washes off easily, stays as long as 8 hours, lightweight.
  • No flaking, no eye irritation.

Cons

  • Some say they experience lash fallout, fibers get messy, fibers don’t stick.  
  • Not good as advertised, just ok.


Organys Lash & Brow Booster Serum Gives You Longer Fuller Thicker Looking Eyelashes & Eyebrows 100% Yours. Best Seller Conditioner Enhances The Appearance Of Natural Lush Eyelash Growth & Regrowth

$35.00
$19.97  in stock
8 new from $19.97
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • SHORT or SPARSE EYELASHES? THIN or OVER PLUCKED EYEBROWS? Your eyelashes break after mascara dries them out, they are pulled out by the eyelash curler, they are damaged from harsh eyelash extension glue, they are ripped by false lashes, or affected by stress, hormones and medical treatments. Your eyebrows have been aggressively plucked for years and are now thin or showing bald spots
  • GET LONGER LOOKING LASHES & THICKER LOOKING BROWS! Natural ingredients will nourish and soften them. They will appear defined and beautiful giving you a big-eyed look that is inspiring and hard to turn away from. You will make a different impact with eye contact! Consider buying two for uninterrupted usage
  • 100,000+ HAVE HAD GREAT EXPERIENCE WITH THIS SERUM. Contains amino-acids that enhance the lashes & brows. Helps maintain healthy and youthful looking lashes and brows. FREE OF color, fragrance, paraben, sulphate, phthalates, SLS, PEG, and gluten. Vegan. Not tested on animals. No prostaglandins
  • OUR GUARANTEE: For best results, use twice daily for 60 days on clean skin before applying makeup. A small portion of users may not respond to the formula. If you are not happy after using the product for 60 days as recommended, return the bottle for 100% REFUND! May cause a warm or tingling feeling on sensitive skin, which should go away in a few minutes. Before starting to use the product, test a small amount on the skin at the base of the eyelashes and wait 48 hours - if there is no redness,
  • [NOTE: Organyc rebranded to Organys, you are getting the same great product from the same great company.] RESPONSIBLY FORMULATED. Organys is an eco-friendly skincare brand committed to minimizing waste and working with responsibly sourced ingredients. Organys Lash & Brow Serum is responsibly formulated with plant-based ingredients and botanical extracts. We pay premium prices for quality ingredients and keep batches small, so they are fresh

Why you need it?

Can’t help to put this in with all the huge reviews. It’s serum, ladies. Not your regular mascara but absolutely does the triick. You want to stay true to your real lashes? Then try the No.1 Best Seller Organys Lash & Brow Booster Serum for growing fuller- and thicker-looking eyelashes and brows. They recommend 60 days and BOOM! Serum has transformed your lashes. Set aside the usual mascara just a bit (give it a break!) and grow and thicken your lovelies naturally instead.

What is it?  

Responsibly formulated eyelash and brow serum with plant-based ingredients and botanical extracts. Contains amino-acids that enhance the lashes & brows. Helps maintain healthy and youthful looking lashes and brows. Free of color, fragrance, paraben, sulphate, phthalates, SLS, PEG, and gluten. Vegan.

May cause a warm or tingling feeling on sensitive skin, which should go away in a few minutes. Before starting to use, test a small amount on the skin at the base of the eyelashes and wait 48 hours – ok to use if there is no redness, swelling, itching or burning on that spot. Tips: Dry the applicator on the bottle edge.

Dip the brush into the serum just enough to pick a drop. Flip the brush upside down for a second for the drop to soak into the brush and not to stay on its tip.

Apply along the upper eyelid at the base of all eyelashes (similar to an eyeliner). Blot the extra serum not to leak into the eyes. Recommended use is twice per day (minimum one time per day) for at least 60 days.

Pros

  • Huge positive reviews: great satisfaction for growing lashes, lashes with length and volume, noticeable results in few days to weeks for some.
  • Easy to follow instructions, best results with twice daily use.
  • For sparse, thin lashes, for loss of lashes due to disease or mascara use.
  • Some take longer (3 to 6 months) to have the lashes desired but are well satisfied.

Cons

  • Product did not work for some buyers, some experienced irritation.  


blinc Lash Primer, Clear, 0.23 Oz.

$20.00  in stock
2 new from $20.00
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • Creates a base coat surrounding lashes for added volume and length that amplifies your mascara's effect
  • Vitamin enriched formula conditions lashes
  • Strengthens lashes and increases resistance to breakage
  • No makeup remover required
  • Protects lashes against environmental stresses

Why you need it?

Try a different way of turning your lashes from thin to full, shorties to long ones. This is not like your conventional mascara. Blinc Mascara applies water-resistant tubes around the lashes and stays in place even if you’re sweaty or you accidentally rub your eyes. You’ll have volume and length and look radiant throughout the day with just one apply. Think of no-hassle, no reapplication kinda’ beauty routine.

What is it?  

No-smudge, water-resistant mascara that last throughout the day with no re-application. Unlike conventional mascaras that are painted on, blinc mascara forms tiny no-smudge, water-resistant “tubes” around the lashes. Once applied, these mascara tubes bind to the lashes and cannot run, smudge, clump, or flake, even if you cry or rub your eyes. Adds volume and length to give you a radiant natural look that lasts all day. Only when you are ready for removal, the tubes will effortlessly slide off your lashes into your hand without the use of a harsh makeup remover.

Pros

  • Many regard the product as the best in the market: magically stays in place all day, not affected by crying, swimming or rubbing, slips off easily with warm water removal.
  • For those who like soft coverage only, for sensitive eyes, recommended for swimmers, mature ladies.
  • System of tube application does not lead to smudging, leaking or smearing.

Cons

  • Some reports of faulty applicator, leaking tubes, clumping and sticking,  


L'Oréal Paris Makeup Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara, Black, 0.33 fl. oz.

$10.95
$9.48  in stock
10 new from $8.99
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • Revolutionary lash extension effect mascara provides up to 80 percent longer looking, nourished lashes - Long-wearing, smudge-proof, easy removal - Ophthalmologist-tested, suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • To Use- Apply Step 1 to lashes and immediately follow with Step 2 - No need to wait for drying time in between - Place each brush at the base of lashes and gently sweep from root to tip
  • Step 1- Nourishing Basecoat- The nourishing base coat is infused with ingredients to protect, nourish and strengthen lashes
  • Step 2- Ultra-Lengthening Topcoat- As the mascara sets, it forms tubes that act like lash-lengthening extensions making lashes look up to 80 percent longer-Lasts all day without smudging, smearing or flaking
  • Step 3- Smudge-Free Removal- The mascara removes with plenty of warm water, without the need for makeup remover

Why you need it?

Talk about those two-step application mascaras that work for you and you’ll say you now barely have the time in the world. That’s because you have to wait for step 1 to dry before you put in step 2. Make it easy with ‘Oréal Paris Makeup Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara. Still get those long, strong lashes you’ve always wanted. And, you’ll be out the door in no time.

What is it?  

0.33 Fl Oz of revolutionary lash extension effect mascara. Nourishing base coat is infused with Ceramide R and D-Panthenol to protect, nourish and strengthen lashes. Ultra-lengthening tube topcoat, as the mascara sets, forms tubes that act like lash-lengthening extensions. No drying time needed in between. Lashes look up to 80% longer. Lasts all day without smudging, smearing or flaking. Smudge-free removal as the mascara tubes remove with plenty of warm water, without the need for makeup remover. Tips: Apply step 1 to lashes, and immediately follow with step 2. Place each brush at the base of lashes and gently sweep up from root to tip. Reserve product for personal use and treat applicator with hygienic care. Cap tightly after use.

Pros

  • Majority call this they’re favorite mascara, love the super long lashes, great for oily eyelids and hooded eyes, worth the effort.
  • Washes off smoothly as tubes with warm water with no smudging or smearing.
  • Stays as long as you want, some keep them on for a few days before wash-off.
  • The best tubing mascara in the market. Good price.

Cons

  • Only a few say the product in not for them, for lengthening only not for thickening.
  • Too much hassle to apply, top coat does not cover well, difficult to remove.  


IT Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara

$24.50
$20.70  in stock
26 new from $15.89
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara: Black
  • Unique Elastic Stretch Technology Wraps Each Individual Lash
  • Formulated With Peptides, Proteins, Biotin, Lash-Enhancing Polymers & Collagen
  • Transforms Lashes With a Super Black Color for the Look of Longer, More Defined Lashes

Why you need it?

Do eyelashes stretch? Well, they apparently do with  IT Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara. The stretch technology is proprietary, each of your lovelies are coated wider and longer, each gets wrapped in volume-boosting, lengthening, ultra-conditioning black cape of power and color. Wow! Be at your best with the most defined eyes. Like some Superhero-ine.

What is it?  

0.30 Fl Oz of a game-changing mascara that’s clinically shown to give lashes super volume, super length and super elastic stretch in just one coat. Lash-lifting polymers, volumizing collagen, strengthening biotin, proteins and peptides combined with super black pigment and the power brush work together to coat every lash from base to tips – lifting lashes while separating them to create a fuller lash line.

No lash is left behind. Tips: Starting at the base of the lashes, wiggle and sweep up and through to the tips. Apply additional coats for more dramatic results. The game-changing formula is completely buildable.

Pros

  • Many say it’s become their favorite mascara, good job at lengthening and volumizing, brush separates well and colors all lashes.
  • No-mess application, no clumping or smudging, easy to work with, long-lasting results.
  • Will not use any other mascara, worth the price.

Cons

  • Some complained product might be an imitation.
  • Product runs out and dries out fast, becomes clumpy and thick towards the end, gross to apply.    


Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara by Simply Naked Beauty. Last All Day, waterproof, smudge proof & hypoallergenic ingredients. non-toxic and natural. Midnight Black

$21.97
$19.99  in stock
1 new from $19.99
Free shipping
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • LIMITED TIME OFFER! Buy 2 and get 10% off using this code on checkout: XOFJI3W2
  • LAST ALL DAY, WATEPROOF & SMUDGE PROOF - Lash Science will last all day, is waterproof, sweat proof and smudge proof. Bring on 24-hour sexy.
  • HIGHEST QUALITY NON-TOXIC, NATURAL & SAFE INGREDIENTS - Lash Science is made from natural, non-irritating and non-toxic ingredients like 100% natural green tea fibers perfect for sensitive skin. Hypoallergenic ingredients and never tested on animals. Paraben free.
  • 300x LASH VOLUME IN 5 MINUTES -Lash Science 3D Fiber mascara will give you the most volume and length outside of extensions, guaranteed.
  • SUPER EASY TO APPLY - With the most detailed and easy to follow directions you have ever seen and a customer support team of beauty specialist, Lash Science goes on so quick, you'll be amazed. Comes off easily and fast.

Why you need it?

If you want to rest from traditional volumizing formulas that give the appearance of volume by clumping lashes together, this absolutely amazing mascara does differently. It comes with a thicker brush base evenly combs through eyelashes from roots to ends, and a tapered tip captures the small, hard-to-reach lashes. With the right smokey eye makeup, your orbs will look really hot.

What is it?  

0.20 Fl Oz of black mascara formulation with kohl-pigment. Note brush is thicker at the base to help comb through middle eyelashes from roots to ends. The tapered tip are for those small, hard-to-reach lashes. Incredibly builds volume to each single lash. Delivers thicker. fuller. bolder lashes in one super-saturated stroke. Gives a dramatic smokey eye look in an instant. Formula is long-wearing and holds against flaking, smudging, humidity and sweat. Brush from base to tips of lashes and let dry.

Pros

  • Most purchasers love the lifting power of the product, lashes are darker, longer and do not flake, good for short lashes.
  • Ophthalmologist-recommended for sensitive eyes.
  • Brush is good, soft and easy to use.
  • Bit pricey but worth it, product can last long.

Cons

  • Some reports of allergic reactions, clumpiness, bad packaging.
  • Expensive for its smallness.


Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara, No. 1 Black, 0.2 Ounce

$22.00  in stock
27 new from $22.00
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • Its thicker brush base combs through eyelashes from roots to ends
  • Tapered tip grabs those small, hard-to-reach lashes
  • Incredibly builds volume to each single lash

Why you need it?

Meet the biggest brush for mascara from Covergirl. COVERGIRL Lashblast 24 Hour Mascara is a blast of lush, indeed. It’s black-brown if you don’t like black. One of Covergirl’s pricey end beauty tool for incredible lashes, a little bit more product and a little bit more brush. If you need to glam up for the night, this is it.

What is it?  

0.44 Fl Oz of intense volume mascara, with big brush providing volumized lashes that last up to 24 hours. Ophthalmologist-tested, it’s suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Hypoallergenic. Removes easily with Covergirl Clean Makeup Remover. Tips: Discard bottle cap. Replace with brush and close cap completely before first use. Hold brush as close as possible to base of lashes, and wiggle it as you move it up through lashes.

Pros

  • A lot of users are amazed by it, mascara can last 2 to 3 days on, no experience of clumping, smudging or flaking,
  • Makes super long, thick lashes that last all day.
  • It’s waterproof, sweatproof.

Cons

  • Very difficult to remove.
  • Some irritation.


COVERGIRL Lashblast 24 Hour Mascara, Black Brown 810, 0.44 Fluid Ounce

$49.99  in stock
1 new from $49.99
Buy Now
Amazon.com
as of July 20, 2019 4:52 PM

Features

  • Bold, intense volume that lasts up to 24 hours
  • Lash blast power, hour after hour
  • Big, bold, look-at-me lashes that last
  • The latest from the lash blast collection

Why you need it?

Meet the biggest brush for mascara from Covergirl. COVERGIRL Lashblast 24 Hour Mascara is a blast of lush, indeed. It’s black-brown if you don’t like black. One of Covergirl’s pricey end beauty tool for incredible lashes, a little bit more product and a little bit more brush. If you need to glam up for the night, this is it.

What is it?  

0.44 Fl Oz of intense volume mascara, with big brush providing volumized lashes that last up to 24 hours. Ophthalmologist-tested, it’s suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Hypoallergenic. Removes easily with Covergirl Clean Makeup Remover. Tips: Discard bottle cap. Replace with brush and close cap completely before first use. Hold brush as close as possible to base of lashes, and wiggle it as you move it up through lashes.

Pros

  • A lot of users are amazed by it, mascara can last 2 to 3 days on, no experience of clumping, smudging or flaking,
  • Makes super long, thick lashes that last all day.
  • It’s waterproof, sweatproof.

Cons

  • Very difficult to remove.
  • Some irritation.

Hi. My name is Emma Carter and I’ve been an online shopaholic since I can remember. Whatever it is I need - a new tank top, makeup, a book, my dinner - it’s such a breeze! Let me help you make fast, reliable and well-informed decisions on your purchases. BestofBest is your go-to site for for all things Health & Beauty for men and women, Home & Kitchen, and Lifestyle.

Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0